LATEST NEWS

REVIEW

Thy Catafalque

XIII: Sárga Erdő

BY INêS DUARTE
Thy Catafalque — XIII: Sárga Erdő album artwork
Thy Catafalque — XIII: Sárga Erdő album artwork

Thy Catafalque has long occupied a peculiar niche in the blackened avant-garde, carving out a sonic identity built on sprawling, glacial movements and a brooding, funerary atmosphere. With their latest offering, 'XIII: Sárga Erdő', the project seems to lean further into its own shadows, blending elements of folk metal into a tapestry of Hungarian-inspired gloom. However, as the clock ticks through this hour-long odyssey, the experience becomes one of overwhelming density rather than nuanced exploration. It is a beautiful, terrifying mess, but one that occasionally buckles under the weight of its own ambition.

Opening with 'Búcsú a piros madártól', the album immediately establishes its aesthetic: vast, cavernous spaces and a crushing sense of isolation. The integration of folk motifs isn't just a stylistic veneer; it feels woven into the very marrow of the composition. Yet, there is a fine line between 'atmosphere' and 'stasis'. In several movements, the transition between the drone-like passages and the more intense bursts of metal feels jagged, as if the music is struggling to decide whether it wants to transport the listener or simply wall them off from the outside world.

A labyrinthine journey where the atmosphere is suffocatingly thick, yet the emotional core remains strangely distant.

By the time we reach 'Ég-anyám, föld-apám', the evocative nature of the folk elements becomes clear. There is a haunting, earthy quality to the melodies that suggests a deep connection to soil and spirit. But this is where the critique of the 'avant-garde' label becomes pertinent. The production is impeccably cold, but the pacing often drags. 'Dunnák alatt kék mező' and 'Szitakötő' suffer from a sense of circularity, where the emotional arc plateaus just as it begins to climb, leaving the listener wandering through a fog that feels intentionally impenetrable but ultimately exhausting.

Technically, the execution is formidable. The interplay of textures is sophisticated, and the way the band handles dynamic shifts is indicative of a high level of craftsmanship. 'Suhamló éji fák' showcases a particularly striking use of space, letting the echoes of the instruments hang in the air like heavy smoke. However, the sheer length of the album means that these moments of genuine beauty are often buried under a mountain of repetitive gloom. The 'Sárga Erdő' (Yellow Forest) of the title feels less like a forest and more like a thicket of thorns, difficult to navigate without losing the thread of the narrative.

In the middle section, 'Puszta' and 'Sirató' lean into the more mournful aspects of the project's identity. The inclusion of these elements provides a visceral, almost tactile sense of mourning. It is here that the project finds its greatest strength—the ability to evoke a sense of profound, ancient sorrow. Yet, even here, the avant-garde flourishes sometimes feel like self-indulgent detours. The music wants to be a monument, but it occasionally forgets to be a journey, standing still in its own grandeur while the listener's attention begins to fray.

As we reach 'Cseremisz' and the title track 'Sárga erdő', the density reaches a boiling point. The folk influences are at their peak, providing a strangely beautiful contrast to the harshness of the metal framework. But by this point, the sonic fatigue sets in. 'Tömbök' and 'Kút vizén nap forog' feel like the echoes of the previous tracks, repeating a sentiment that has already been stated a dozen times. The 'avant-garde' element, while commendable in its ambition, occasionally results in a lack of melodic direction that makes the latter half of the album feel like a repetitive loop.

The final movement, '87 tavasz, 87 ősz', provides a somber, reflective closing. It attempts to synthesize the preceding hour into a single, cohesive statement of passage. While it succeeds in creating a haunting exit, it cannot fully rectify the fact that the album's journey was often too winding to remain engaging. Thy Catafalque has created a work of undeniable atmospheric power, but it is a cold, distant beauty. It is a masterful piece of world-building that ultimately feels like a labyrinth where the walls are made of heavy, grey stone. It is impressive, but it is not easy to inhabit.

Ultimately, 'XIII: Sárga Erdő' is a polarizing piece of high-concept metal. It rewards the patient listener with flashes of genuine, haunting beauty and a deep, evocative atmosphere. However, its commitment to the 'avant-garde' means it often sacrifices momentum for mood. It is a sprawling, overgrown forest—beautiful to look at from a distance, but increasingly difficult to navigate as one walks through its thicket. It is a high-art achievement that, while artistically commendable, fails to strike the heart with the visceral punch required to elevate it into the realm of a masterpiece. It remains a fascinating, albeit punishing, listen.

BROWSE LATEST ARTICLES →