REVIEW
Silent Planet
SUPERBLOOM
With the release of SUPERBLOOM, Silent Planet enters a territory of extreme architectural complexity. As a staple of the progressive metalcore scene, the band has long been defined by their willingness to weave intricate, avant-garde textures into heavy frameworks. However, on this latest outing, the line between sophisticated composition and indulgent self-indulgence becomes perilously thin. The production is clinical, providing a sharp, high-fidelity canvas for the technicality to unfold, but it occasionally feels too sterile to allow the underlying atmosphere to breathe.
Opening with "Lights off the Lost Coast," the band establishes a sprawling dynamic. The transition from atmospheric passages into high-velocity technicality is seamless, yet it sets a precedent for the album's structure: a constant oscillation between the ethereal and the abrasive. While the musicianship is undeniably elite, the sheer density of the arrangements often leaves little room for the listener to inhabit the space. It is a demanding listen, requiring constant attention to the shifting time signatures and the rapid-fire polyrhythms.
Complexity is not a substitute for cohesion; SUPERBLOOM is a masterclass in intricate, yet ultimately hollow, construction.
"Offworlder" and "Collider" showcase the band's ability to weave melodic hooks into jagged, jagged-edged structures. The guitar work is precise, utilizing complex tapping and unconventional scales that push the boundaries of the genre. Yet, in these instances, the technicality feels like the primary objective. The songwriting occasionally prioritises the 'wow' factor of a difficult passage over the organic flow of the song. It is a common pitfall in progressive metalcore, where the complexity becomes the point rather than the vehicle for the message.
As the record progresses into "Euphoria" and "Dreamwalker," the melodic elements become more pronounced. Here, the contrast between the soaring vocals and the crushing weight of the riffs is most palpable. However, the transition points between these sections can feel somewhat abrupt, as if the band is checking off boxes in a pre-determined structural blueprint. The ambition is evident, but the cohesion of the overarching narrative—if one can call it that—is occasionally sacrificed for the sake of variety.
"Antimatter" and ":Signal:" represent the peak of the album's technical ambition. The percussion is punishing, and the interplay between the guitars is sophisticated. Yet, it is in these moments that the fatigue begins to set in. When every bar contains a new rhythmic twist or a sudden shift in texture, the listener's ability to connect emotionally with the music is diluted. It is a formidable display of skill, but it lacks the 'gut-punch' simplicity that defines the most enduring metalcore anthems.
"Anunnaki" and "The Overgrowth" attempt to ground the record with more traditional, heavy-hitting structures. These tracks provide a necessary reprieve from the more abstract passages, but they also highlight the inconsistency of the album's pacing. The shift from the avant-garde to the conventional feels less like a deliberate stylistic choice and more like a concession to the genre's expectations. The production remains consistent, but the emotional arc of the music feels somewhat fragmented.
Closing with "Nexus," "Reentry," and the title track "SUPERBLOOM," the album reaches a fever pitch of activity. The final movements are a whirlwind of activity, aiming for a grand, cinematic conclusion. While the technical execution is flawless, the sheer volume of information delivered in the final third makes it difficult to distinguish one movement from the next. It is a dense, demanding piece of work that demands a high level of concentration from the listener.
Ultimately, SUPERBLOOM is a testament to Silent Planet's technical prowess. They are masters of their craft, capable of executing incredibly complex musical ideas with precision. However, by leaning so heavily into the 'progressive' aspect of their identity, they have created a work that is intellectually stimulating but emotionally distant. It is a formidable achievement of engineering, but it lacks the cohesive soul that would elevate it from a technical exercise to a masterpiece. It is a solid, if somewhat over-engineered, addition to their discography.